By Muhammad Ali Khan · Updated 2026-11-15
The short answer
A 1099 contract has to pay noticeably more than a W-2 salary to leave you with the same money. As a contractor you pay both halves of Social Security and Medicare tax, you buy your own equipment, and you get no employer benefits. In 2026, a single filer weighing an $85,000 salary against contract work with $6,000 of expenses needs about $97,399 of contract pay just to match the salary's take-home after federal tax. If the job also comes with $9,000 a year of benefits, that rises to about $111,155.
Why the same number is not the same pay
On a W-2 job your employer withholds 6.2% for Social Security on wages up to the 2026 wage base of $184,500, and 1.45% for Medicare. The employer pays a matching 7.65% that never appears on your pay stub. As a contractor you pay self-employment tax instead. It applies to 92.35% of your net profit at 15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security up to the same $184,500 cap, plus 2.9% for Medicare on everything. You deduct half of that self-employment tax when working out adjusted gross income, which softens the hit a little.
The second difference is expenses. An employer supplies the laptop, software and workspace. A contractor pays for them, so the tax calculation starts from profit, which is pay minus business expenses, and not from the headline rate.
The third difference does not appear in any tax table: benefits. Employer-paid health premiums, a retirement match and paid time off are real money. The calculator leaves those boxes blank because they differ from one offer to the next. Enter what your offer letter says, or the comparison will flatter the contract.
A worked example: $85,000 salary against a $100,000 contract
Take a single filer using the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100. On the W-2 side, Social Security is 6.2% of $85,000, which is $5,270.00, and Medicare is 1.45%, which is $1,232.50. Taxable income is $85,000 minus $16,100, or $68,900. The 2026 single schedule charges $1,240 on the first $12,400, $4,560 on the next $38,000 and 22% of the $18,500 above $50,400, which is $4,070, for $9,870.00 of income tax. Take-home pay before state tax is $68,627.50.
On the 1099 side, $100,000 of contract pay less $6,000 of expenses leaves $94,000 of profit. Net earnings subject to self-employment tax are 92.35% of that, $86,809.00. Social Security is 12.4% of it, $10,764.32, and Medicare is 2.9%, $2,517.46, so self-employment tax is $13,281.78. Half of that, $6,640.89, comes off your income. Taxable income is $94,000 minus $6,640.89 minus $16,100, or $71,259.11, which brings $10,389.00 of income tax. Take-home pay is $70,329.22.
On paper the contract pays $15,000 more. After tax and expenses it leaves you $1,701.72 ahead, and that is before counting any benefits you would give up.
The break-even pay, with and without benefits
The break-even pay is the contract amount that leaves you with exactly the W-2 take-home. For this example it is $97,398.96, which is 14.6% above the $85,000 salary. Now suppose the salary job would also give you $6,000 of employer-paid health premiums, a $2,000 retirement match and $1,000 of paid time off, $9,000 in all. The comparison then has to match $77,627.50, and the break-even contract pay becomes $111,155.24, or 30.8% above the salary. At the $100,000 contract you are $7,298.28 behind.
If the contract is hourly, divide the break-even by the hours you will really bill, not by 2,080. At 40 hours a week for 48 paid weeks, which is 1,920 hours, $97,398.96 works out to $50.73 an hour, and $111,155.24 to $57.89 an hour. Fewer paid weeks push the hourly figure up, because the same yearly amount is spread over fewer hours.
What moves the answer
Expenses move it almost dollar for dollar. With no business expenses at all, the break-even pay for the same $68,627.50 of take-home is $91,398.96. With $12,000 of expenses it is $103,398.96. Each extra dollar you spend must be earned back before it counts as pay.
Filing status matters through the standard deduction, the brackets and the Additional Medicare Tax threshold. That tax is 0.9% and applies above $200,000 for single filers, $250,000 for married filing jointly and $125,000 for married filing separately. It affects both sides, because employees and contractors both owe it once earnings pass the threshold.
What the comparison leaves out
The calculator compares federal income tax and payroll taxes only. State and local income taxes, the qualified business income deduction, tax credits and retirement contributions are not modelled, and each of them can move the answer either way. The QBI deduction can help contractors, while a retirement match helps employees. If either one matters to you, treat the result as a starting point for a conversation with a tax professional.
Contract income is also not guaranteed. Gaps between clients, unpaid admin time and the chance a contract ends early all argue for treating the break-even as a floor and not a target.
Common mistakes
Comparing gross to gross is the most common one. A $100,000 contract is not $15,000 better than an $85,000 salary, and in the example it was $1,701.72 better. Forgetting the employer half comes next: a W-2 employer pays 7.65% on top of your salary, and as a contractor that cost moves to you.
Ignoring expenses is a third mistake, since every dollar of business cost reduces both take-home and taxable profit. Leaving benefits at zero is a fourth, because even a rough number is better than none. The last is assuming a contract runs all year: if you expect gaps, lower the weeks before you compare.
To run your own figures, open the 1099 vs W-2 calculator, and see the freelancer hub for the related tools.
Tools used in this guide
Official sources
More guides: Self-employment tax in 2026, How much does an employee really cost?.