By Muhammad Ali Khan · Updated 2026-11-15
The two headline rates
Both companies charge a percentage of each payment plus a fixed amount, so the cost of a payment is rate × amount + fixed fee. For a domestic card, Stripe charges 2.9% + $0.30. PayPal Checkout, which also covers Venmo and other commercial payments, charges 3.49% + $0.49. On a $100 payment that is $3.20 for Stripe and $3.98 for PayPal, leaving you $96.80 or $96.02.
PayPal publishes several other rates for US merchants, and the calculator holds all of them: standard credit and debit cards at 2.99% + $0.49, goods and services at 2.99% with no fixed fee, Pay Later at 4.99% + $0.49 and QR code payments at 2.29% + $0.09. Stripe adds ACH Direct Debit at 0.8% capped at $5.00.
One $100 payment on every rate
Run $100.00 through each rate and the spread is wide. PayPal Pay Later costs $5.48 and PayPal Checkout $3.98. A standard card through PayPal costs $3.48, Stripe's card costs $3.20, and goods and services costs $2.99. QR is $2.38 and ACH is $0.80.
The cheapest rate for a business is therefore not a provider but a payment method. A customer who pays by bank debit costs a quarter of Stripe's card fee at this size. The table in the calculator shows the same payment on every rate at once, with the effective percentage, so you can see where a given amount lands.
Why small payments lose more
The fixed fee does not shrink with the sale. On a $5.00 payment, Stripe's card fee is $0.15 + $0.30 = $0.45, or 9% of the sale. PayPal Checkout takes $0.66, which is 13.2%. On $1,000 the same two rates cost $29.30 (2.93%) and $35.39 (3.54%), so the effective rate falls toward the headline rate as the payment grows.
That matters if you sell low-priced items. A minimum order, a bundled price or a rate with a smaller fixed fee, such as QR at $0.09, can save more than switching providers.
Where goods and services beats a card rate
PayPal's goods-and-services rate has no fixed fee, which makes it cheaper than Stripe's card rate on small payments and dearer on large ones. The two are equal where 2.99% of the amount equals 2.9% of the amount plus $0.30, which is a payment of $333.33. At $100 goods and services costs $2.99 against Stripe's $3.20. At $1,000 it costs $29.90 against $29.30.
The calculator only compares the published rates. Whether a particular payment can be taken at a given rate depends on PayPal's terms and how the customer pays, so confirm that in your account before you plan around a rate.
International cards, manual entry and currency conversion
Extras add to the percentage, not the fixed fee. Stripe adds 0.5% for a card entered by hand, 1.5% for an international card and 1% when currency conversion is needed. On $100 an international card at 4.4% + $0.30 costs $4.70, and with conversion as well it is 5.4% + $0.30, or $5.70. PayPal adds 1.50% to international commercial transactions, so Checkout becomes 4.99% + $0.49 and costs $5.48 on $100.
The calculator applies PayPal's international addition to its commercial rates but not to goods and services, because the international rate for that is not in the schedule it uses. ACH ignores all of these options.
Charging so you receive an exact amount
If you want to receive $100.00 rather than lose a few dollars from it, add the fixed fee to the target and divide by one minus the rate. With Stripe that is ($100.00 + $0.30) ÷ 0.971 = $103.30, rounded up to the cent. The fee on $103.30 is $3.30, and you keep $100.00. With PayPal Checkout the same target needs $104.13.
A common slip is to add the fee on $100 to the target. That gives $103.20, but the fee is taken from the larger amount: it is $3.29 on $103.20, so you keep $99.91. That is why you divide instead of adding.
ACH has a cap, so the sum changes for large payments. To receive $1,000.00 by ACH you charge $1,005.00, because the fee reaches the $5.00 cap at $625.00 and stays there.
Disputes and refunds
Stripe charges a $15.00 dispute fee. It does not charge a fee to refund a card payment, but it does not return the original processing fee either. If you refund a $100.00 card payment you pay back the $100.00 and have already lost the $3.20, so the sale cost you money.
These costs are not in the fee result. They matter most on low-margin items, where one dispute can wipe out the profit from many sales.
A $25 sale as a second check
A mid-sized payment shows the same pattern. On $25.00, Stripe's card rate costs $1.03, or 4.12% of the sale, and PayPal Checkout costs $1.36, or 5.44%. The gap is $0.33 on one sale, which looks small, but across a few hundred sales a month it is real money. Run your own typical order through the calculator rather than relying on the headline rates, because the fixed fee changes which rate is cheapest as the amount moves.
Checking the figures
PayPal's rates come from its US merchant fee schedule, last updated November 4, 2026, and Stripe's from its US pricing page. Your own agreement can differ, for example with volume pricing, so compare the result with a real statement. The calculator is for choosing a rate and a price, and the official pages are linked below.
Tools used in this guide
Official sources
More guides: Etsy fees in 2026, KDP royalties in 2026.