By Muhammad Ali Khan · Updated 2026-11-15
The short answer
An S corporation can cut payroll taxes because only the salary you pay yourself carries Social Security and Medicare tax. Profit you take out as distributions does not. The saving is real only when the business earns clearly more than a reasonable salary for the work you do, and when the difference is big enough to cover the extra cost of running payroll and a separate tax return. With $120,000 of profit and a $60,000 salary, the 2026 payroll-tax saving is about $5,733 a year after $2,000 of extra costs. With $70,000 of profit and a $45,000 salary it shrinks to $963.69.
What to gather before you run the numbers
You need four things: your net profit before any owner pay, the salary you would pay yourself, your state's unemployment rate and wage base, and quotes for the extra yearly cost of running payroll, a separate tax return and state fees. The last two are easy to leave out, and leaving them out makes the saving look bigger than it is.
How the saving works
As a sole proprietor or single-member LLC taxed that way, you pay self-employment tax on 92.35% of your profit. The rate is 15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security up to the 2026 wage base of $184,500, plus 2.9% for Medicare with no cap.
As an S corp shareholder-employee you are on payroll. Your salary carries the employee share, 6.2% Social Security plus 1.45% Medicare, and the corporation pays the same again, so the salary is taxed at 15.3% too. The corporation also owes federal unemployment tax on the first $7,000 of wages. The rate is 6.0%, or 0.6% after the full state credit, which is $42 a year. Your state charges its own unemployment tax with a rate and wage base it sets, so the calculator leaves that for you to enter.
Whatever profit is left after salary and costs can be paid as a distribution, and distributions are not subject to employment taxes. That is the whole source of the saving.
The catch: reasonable compensation
The IRS requires an S corporation to pay a shareholder-employee reasonable compensation before taking non-wage distributions, and it can reclassify distributions as wages if the salary is too low. It gives no percentage and no safe-harbor formula. The factors it lists include training and experience, duties, time devoted to the business, dividend history, what non-shareholder employees are paid, what comparable businesses pay for similar services, compensation agreements and the use of a formula.
That is why the calculator makes salary an input you choose and never suggests a percentage. Rules of thumb such as a 60/40 split do not come from the IRS. A defensible salary is closer to what you would have to pay someone else to do your job.
Worked example one: $120,000 profit, $60,000 salary
As a sole proprietor, net earnings are 92.35% of $120,000, or $110,820. Social Security at 12.4% is $13,741.68 and Medicare at 2.9% is $3,213.78, so self-employment tax is $16,955.46.
As an S corp, employer and employee FICA on the $60,000 salary is 15.3%, or $9,180.00, and FUTA adds $42.00. State unemployment tax is left at zero here as an example. Employment taxes are $9,222.00. If the S corp costs $2,000 a year more to run in payroll service, extra tax preparation and state fees, which is an example you should replace with your own quotes, the estimated saving is $16,955.46 minus $9,222.00 minus $2,000, or $5,733.46.
Worked example two: when the saving nearly vanishes
Now take $70,000 of profit and a $45,000 salary. Sole proprietor self-employment tax is $9,890.69. S corp employment taxes are 15.3% of $45,000 plus $42, which is $6,927.00. After the same $2,000 of costs the saving is $963.69. Add a state unemployment bill or a pricier accountant and it can turn negative.
The salary matters as much as the profit. If the $120,000 business paid an $80,000 salary instead of $60,000, employment taxes rise to $12,282.00 and the saving drops to $2,673.46. And if profit is $60,000 with a $55,000 salary, the S corp costs $1,979.27 more than it saves. The pattern is simple: the saving grows with the gap between profit and a reasonable salary, and the fixed costs of the S corp eat into it from the bottom.
What the calculator does not model
It compares payroll taxes only. It does not model income-tax effects, and those can shift the result. A sole proprietor deducts half of self-employment tax, while an S corp deducts the employer half of FICA as a business expense. The qualified business income deduction is calculated differently once part of your income is wages. State income and franchise taxes vary, and retirement contributions based on salary shrink when the salary does.
Treat the output as the payroll-tax part of the decision. The election itself, and the salary you settle on, are worth reviewing with a CPA or enrolled agent who knows your state.
Common mistakes
Choosing a salary to maximize the saving is the first. A salary set by the tax result and not by the work is exactly what the IRS reclassifies. Forgetting the running costs is the second: payroll software, payroll filings, a separate corporate return and state fees are paid every year, even in a bad one.
Electing too early is the third. If profit is close to a reasonable salary there is little left to distribute and nothing to save. Ignoring state unemployment tax is the fourth, since it applies to your own wages too. The last is looking only at this year. Profit swings, so run the calculator for a lean year as well as a good one.
Tools used in this guide
Official sources
More guides: Self-employment tax in 2026, How much does an employee really cost?.